A Tale of Two Chocolate Bars

If recent market fluctuations have your head spinning, you’re not alone!

This brief story explains that tariffs are complex, have unintended consequences, and are often misunderstood. What are tariffs? Who imposes them and why? How do they impact global markets, your portfolio, and your pocketbook?

Once upon a time, there were two magical countries: Narnia and Timbuktu. Narnia was famous for its super delicious chocolate bars—everyone loved them! On the other hand, Timbuktu also made chocolate bars, but they weren’t quite as tasty as those from Narnia. So, people in Timbuktu started buying more and more chocolate from Narnia.

The leaders of Timbuktu were worried. They thought, “If everyone keeps buying Narnian chocolate, our chocolate factories could lose money, and jobs could be at risk!” So, they decided to add a tariff—basically, a tax—on chocolate bars coming from Narnia. The key takeaway is that a tariff is a tax imposed by a government on its own people. Timbuktu made the tariff 50%. That means if a Narnian chocolate bar typically costs $2, it would now cost $3 in Timbuktu ($2 for the bar + $1 tax). The assumption is that price affects people’s choices, and Timbuktu chocolate lovers will now prefer to enjoy Timbuktu chocolate, made in Timbuktu!

Now that the Narnian chocolate bars cost $3, the people of Timbuktu had to choose: pay more for the tasty Narnian chocolate or the local chocolate, which was still $2. Some people still bought the Narnian chocolate because they loved it, but many more people started buying Timbuktu chocolate again, because it was cheaper. This helped Timbuktu’s chocolate factories stay open and keep workers employed. Narnia lost a lot of business from Timbuktu, and now the Narnian chocolate factory is not selling the amount of chocolate it was before the tax, I mean tariff, was imposed.

But there were other downsides too. The people of Timbuktu now had fewer choices and had to pay more if they wanted the delicious Narnian chocolate. Also, in many cases, local Timbuktu chocolate makers didn’t feel the need to improve their chocolate, since they didn’t have to compete as much with Narnian chocolate treats. So, while tariffs can protect jobs and local businesses, they can also make things more expensive, restrict what people can buy, and decrease competition.

The story illustrates how tariffs, though intended to help domestic businesses, often come with trade-offs for consumers and the broader market. In the end, tariffs may protect some chocolate factories, but they come at a cost—and it’s the chocolate lovers who often pay the price.

Effects on Timbuktu’s Economy:
• Helps local chocolate factories stay open by making foreign chocolate more expensive
• Protects jobs in the chocolate-making industry
• Generates money for Timbuktu’s government through the tariff tax
• Raises prices for consumers who still want Narnian chocolate
• Reduces consumer choice since fewer people can afford the imported chocolate
• May reduce pressure on local businesses to improve quality or lower prices
• Hurts Timbuktu chocolate companies’ profits from initially absorbing the tariff for their customers

Effects on Narnia’s Economy:
• Decreases chocolate sales to Timbuktu because of the higher prices
• Hurts Narnian chocolate companies’ profits from exports
• Could lead to job losses in Narnia’s chocolate factories if exports drop a lot
• Encourages Narnia to find new markets or trade partners who don’t charge tariffs

Timbuktu’s Stock Market (the country imposing the tariff):
• Local chocolate companies’ stocks may go up because they’re selling more chocolate now that the foreign one is more expensive
• Investors might feel confident in industries protected by the tariff (like chocolate), so they buy more stocks in those companies
• But some other industries might get hurt if Narnia fights back with their own tariffs (called a trade war), so investors may worry about long-term risks
• If tariffs make prices rise too much, consumer spending could drop, and that could hurt the stock market overall

Narnia’s Stock Market (the exporter being hit with the tariff):
• Chocolate companies’ stocks might fall, since they’re losing sales in Timbuktu
• Investor confidence may drop if they think tariffs will keep spreading and hurt more industries
• Companies might need to shift strategies—like finding new markets—which could make stock prices bounce up or down depending on how well they adapt
• If other countries see Narnia struggling, they might worry about global trade slowing down, which can pull down markets worldwide

Why do we plan?

Knowing where you are translates into knowing where you're going, and we hope to provide every client with the trust and confidence to navigate through the waters of their financial lives.

Learn More